Friday, February 15, 2008

Is Voting the Best Solution

In the current broken political arena, here are some new ideas. You may not agree with them all but perhaps this can be a starting point for a new discussion. While many people feel not voting is apathetic, I disagree. This is not about one man not voting, it is trying get a large collective of people not voting as a national demonstration against a system that is no longer representing us - the people of the United States...

We, the United States of America, are the greatest nation on Earth. We are compassionate, inclusive, and safe. Yet over the past few decades we have begun the fall from this position. We are a nation with a government of the people, by the people, and for the people and it is this government – not the people – that is failing.

Our current two party system has divided the country like never before. Even though it may seem like we have so much choice, this choice is just an illusion. It becomes difficult to support a candidate we know can't be elected. The favored candidates are always the ones with the most money and can therefore "market" themselves better than the others.

Personal, party, and corporate money supplies these "marketing" efforts. Even the "Get Out the Vote" campaigns are financed by the same sources. Therefore we end up with candidates that, although we don't believe in, become a "lesser of two evils".

I don't want to vote for a "lesser of two evils" candidate, I want to choose greatness! Our current money driven system doesn't allow for greatness to break through because true greatness in a candidate would have the nation's people as the main agenda rather than corporate policy or international interests. I know we are in an irreversible global economy and I am not speaking about protectionism. A candidate that truly puts the American people first won't get the needed monetary support. We need to start doing things differently.

I say to you all, the people of our great nation, that it is time to show our discontent and be civilly disobedient, which was a founding tool of this country, and not participate any longer. Don't participate in a system driven by money and where our choice doesn't include a choice for greatness.

If enough of us decide not to play this game any longer, real change can begin to occur. Perhaps a system that is open to other parties or where other voices get equal time to be heard will result in better candidates. Any businessman knows that competition makes the product better. There is so much negative propaganda being thrown around between all the current candidates that if it were even half true, why would we want these people as our leaders.

A law degree and time in congress doesn't guarantee a great candidate and neither does being a preacher or a CEO. Candidates should be required to have certain skills and character traits that I believe we could collectively agree, contribute to making a potentially great candidate. We talk about athletes or actors being role models, how about our leaders being great role models first and again recognizing that that alone will not make a great candidtae either.

I also realize that greatness varies from county to country and we need to select a greatness based on what we are as a nation. We need to recognize certain inalienable rights as the founders of this country stated and that we are "endowed by our Creator".. This does not exclude anyone. An atheist can participate but should also recognize this foundation, his views may vary but the foundation exists.

We also need to understand our freedom, which is of highest priority but that doesn't mean changing rules or laws to favor one group over another. It does mean that everyone is free to choose how they want to live within our system of laws and be able to do so without persecution.
As with anyone that complains, the question will come…what would you do? I am not a lawyer, a preacher, or a CEO. I am an average American citizen that knows we need a change. I don't have all the answers nor the experience, perhaps, to even ask the right questions but I do know our system is broken. So as not to be a coward and refrain from answering or dodging the question, the following ideas are suggestions from my humble place that, I believe, would have some merit.

1) Education: Education should be at the top of our priority list by far. Excellent education will help solve some of our problems on its own and can take care of parts of other issues along the way. While we should not leave anyone behind, "No Child Left Behind" is only teaching to a lower common denominator and we deserve better. The current of idea of adding 100,000 new teachers is simply a start. We need to go much farther than that and there are many small successful programs that we can take pieces from to have a positive effect on a larger scale.
2) War: The war needs to stop or at least be minimized immediately. There is no reason to lose life and waste resources the way it is currently happening. Pointing fingers at guys like Musharraf for wasting billions, and that is billions with a "b", is ridiculous. Where is the accountability on our side that gave him the money in the first place? The 100,000 new teachers is already causing budget concerns but if the war machine was in check, the 5-10 billion dollars needed annually for the teacher program is not an issue at all. We are spending that much for a month in Iraq.
3) Taxes: The average person pays more than enough taxes. I believe we should have an entertainment tax. This would be for athletes, actors, musicians, celebrities, etc. that make above $5 million per year. Above $5 million, there would be a 50% tax that would be paid directly into the communities where the person lives or works to pay for education, the homeless, healthcare, or other social programs. CEOs would also fall under this tax too, unless the total annual compensation didn't exceed some reasonable multiple of the lowest paid worker. People would still be free to make as much money as they can, but when athletes are making $10-15 million a year, actors are making $20 million a picture, or a CEO that does a poor job walks with a compensation package of $40 million, something is out of whack!
4) Health Care: Health care must be available to everyone. Perhaps some of the entertainment tax would help in this area. Mostly though the legal and insurance systems must be revised regarding health care. Costs skyrocket because of insurance and litigation.
5) The Environment: We are at a critical time here. Maybe you believe in global warming, maybe you don't. If we do something about it and it happens that global warming is not true, we simply end up with a cleaner, healthier, more sustainable planet. If we do nothing and global warming isn't true, then no big deal. But if we do nothing and global warming is true, then we have a catastrophic situation for the planet and a questionable future for our children. Doing something seems like the only reasonable option. Steps such as mandating 35 mpg vehicles by 2020 are a joke. We have the technology to do this tomorrow if we want!
6) Our Sovereignty: As our nation developed, did we make mistakes? Sure we did but we can't look back. We will never not have slavery as a part of our history. It's important to understand it, learn from it, and make sure it never happens again and think about a current context "...of all men created equal with certain inalienable rights..." Now we are the United States of America. We are an English speaking sovereign nation. Why is it so hard to say we want to have English as our national language? We have our own borders and our own laws and we do welcome everyone here. Yet, if you need a picture for your driver's license, you can't wear a burkha. If you need a social security card for a job, you must register in this country properly. This is not discrimination; it's our country's laws. We all must abide by them without distinction. We don't require anyone to speak English or take off your burkha but we shouldn't change our laws to serve the few and we shouldn't be forced to do things in other languages.

Finally, these issues seem like common sense and I know many people in my circle feel as I do. They really shouldn't offend anyone either but somehow they always do. I believe the reason is because our government has failed us. It is no longer of the people, by the people, and for the people. We have given our country over to career politicians and corporate interests that have self serving agendas and not the agenda of the American people first. I believe this has happened because our current system forces us to choose our leaders based on "the lesser of two evils" idea and not on a selection for greatness. Until I have a choice for greatness, I won't vote!

12 comments:

Meghan said...

I agree that the US is LONG overdue for a change. Not voting is a start. We need something larger, stronger more captivating to make an impression because so many people don't vote out of laziness, apathy or ignorance. How do we separate ourselves from this group? How do we do this peacefully?

mike said...

Listen to yourselves: "not voting is a start" -like passive sheep. Try grass roots activism -and vote! Not voting for Obama is 1 for McCain, do the math.

Brad said...

I agree with your statement of the problem, and with some of the outcomes you propose. But you leave out the whole middle thing: the mechanism for achieving the outcomes. Non-participation means that, without a proposal for HOW those outcomes will actually occur, you abandon the field to those who are already adept at manipulating the "broken system" or to those who are already passively accepting it. This will achieve nothing but strengthening the status quo - which is the exact opposite of change.

Anonymous said...

I just wanted to say I really appreciated this email, You brought out my true feelings well at least pointed them out to me. On at least the reason as to why I don't vote Thanks and please keep me on your list

Anonymous said...

Ned for President!

Anonymous said...

I agree with your basic assessment of today’s political culture and the solutions you’ve put forward.

That being said, I’m willing to take the gamble that Obama will get more youth engaged in our political process and that bodes well for future change, and take a small step towards starting a fresh political discourse in this country. While he will still have to cut deals and work with the ‘establishment’ to get things done, I’d rather vote for him and hope for that small change to begin as well as have a voice in preventing McCain from getting in. I certainly respect your point of view and I believe it is driven by an accurate portrayal of where we’re going wrong.

Anonymous said...

Thank you for sending me this I really enjoyed your views am not offended in any way and am in agreement with you on all fronts but one, Tax's. My personal belief is that the Fedral Reserve is an illegal entity and no matter how much money you make or how you make it the government has no right to be a 50/50 partner with any company or individual, taxation without representation was the reason this country sought independence in the first place & now we find ourselves paying excessive taxes to the bloodlines of the people our forefathers rebelled against in the first place. My view on taxes is that excessive corporate welfare, subsidies, corrupt contractors, military spending and globalization needs to be the fat trimmed off the carcass and I like you believe that we need to spend our money on the important stuff like education, health care, social security, emergency relief & infrastructure, and even that works better with the Eisenhower method of using our military to build our infrastructure. Basically I think that the Government needs to have a cap of 20% that they can take from any individual or company, people should be allowed to prosper, corrupt multinational groups need to get their greedy paws out of our treasury and the government needs to learn to function on the funds allotted. Imagine how lucrative we would become to business's to be based here, who wouldn't want to have their company or personal wealth stored someplace where they let you keep most of it? Oh yeah that might not work, as it sits the largest corporations don't pay taxes & receive billions of dollars in subsidies & incentives. Ideally the fedral government would stop believing that it has any autonomy or independent power and that it is the manager of its citizens & realize that all government employees work for the People and need to start treating us like their employer & not like property.


I believe that "of the people, by the people & for the people" means that the government was never meant to have independent power & no other duty or purpose but to serve the people it represents and we need to follow the advice of Thomas Jefferson & take the power back. The idea of an orchestrated voter protest through non-vote is appealing to me, I think there should a write in for restructure and a well articulated restructurization bill accompanied by a clause that states that if a significant number of people greater than votes cast do not vote & write in "restructure" as their vote that it would nullify the vote and the participants in the protest would observe no candidate until restructure has occurred and citizens would not comply with government authority until the majority was recognized. To accompany this I would orchestrate a tax revolt that had every citizen who aligned with this vote demanded that employers redirected their tax withholdings to a secured neutral interest bearing account until the case of the citizens of the United States of America vs the Illegitimate Governing Body & Contracted Fedral Reserve of the United States of America could have their day in International Court.


You got me all fired up and inspired, I went on rambling far too long.

Anonymous said...

I agrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrreeeeeeee!

Anonymous said...

I admire your talent on this, but I think the govt. is handling more important things like whether or not Roger Clemens took steroids.

Anonymous said...

My vote will be for Obama.. as long as he's not a religious
freak.. will suss it out. The USA needs a leader that twists the way the world looks at the US ...
A female or Afro American president both would shake up the way the world sees and the US country runs but I think the bigger and more atypical leader the better to make the USA the "greatest nation on earth' (behind
Australia of course!)....

Anonymous said...

I totally agree with the whole article. Thanks for sending it.

WW said...

A voter boycott is an interesting concept. Given the large percentage of eligible voters who do not vote, perhaps we are close.

Just curious...what would happen if no one voted in the upcoming presidential election? Would the speaker of the house take the office?

WW